Top Picks for Cribs in 2025

Muratore uses the federal safety standard for cribs as a blueprint and also checks the integrity of the mattress support, the materials used in construction (including hardware and fasteners), and any defects or inconsistencies in the crib’s finishes. 

Her team also assesses:

• How easy a crib is to assemble, whether assembly can be managed by one person, and how clear the instructions are. “This can be a pain point when you’re rushing to get your baby’s nursery ready,” Muratore says.

• How simple it is to change the mattress height, which you’ll need to do as your baby grows.

• Design choices, like how accessible the baby is in the crib, the front rail height, and the type of mattress support used. All of these can affect how functional a crib will be.

Consumer Reports tested 34 cribs from retailers including Babyletto, DaVinci Baby, Ikea, Pottery Barn, and Stokke to find the best. The three models that impressed our testers the most are our Top Picks for Cribs for 2025.

CR’s Top Pick for Cribs, below, is the highest-rated widely available model from our rigorous lab tests. We’ve also designated a Value Pick for Cribs that offers a great test score for a good price. And our Expert Pick won top marks for great design, features, and ease of use for a wide range of caregivers.